From 27 September 2026, Directive (EU) 2024/825 — the Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive — bans a specific list of environmental claims on consumer packaging across all 27 member states. “climate-friendly packaging” becomes prohibited. “100 % of energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources” stays legal. The difference is not the fact; it is whether the specification sits next to the claim, on the same medium. There is no transition period and no exemption for old stock: cans already printed, ordered, shipped or sitting on a retailer’s shelf are in scope. This is a guide for canned-food brands and the people who buy their packaging.
Two sentences about the same can. From 27 September 2026, one of them is unlawful.
“climate-friendly packaging.”
“100 % of energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources.”
Both are environmental claims. The first is generic — it suggests excellent environmental performance without saying what that performance is, so from 27 September it is prohibited unless you can point to an EU Ecolabel or an equivalent officially recognised scheme. The second is specific — it names a measurable thing in clear terms on the same medium, so it survives, provided you can substantiate it.
Neither example is an interpretation. Both are written into Recital 9 of the directive itself: “For example, the claim ‘climate-friendly packaging’ would be a generic claim, whilst claiming that ‘100 % of energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources’ would be a specific claim, which would not fall under this prohibition, without prejudice to other provisions of Directive 2005/29/EC remaining applicable to those specific claims. Furthermore, a claim made in written form or orally combined with implicit claims such as colours or images could constitute a generic environmental claim.”. The legislator chose packaging to illustrate the rule.
If your canned line carries the first sentence, or a green leaf next to the word “sustainable”, or a self-made eco-badge your agency designed, you have an artwork problem with a fixed date.
What actually changes on 27 September
Directive (EU) 2024/825 entered into force on 26 March 2024. Member states had to transpose it by 27 March 2026. It applies from 27 September 2026.
It does not create a new standalone regime. It amends two existing directives — the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC) and the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU) — and it does so in two layers that behave very differently:
| Layer | How it works | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Annex I blacklist (new points 2a, 4a, 4b, 4c, 10a) | Prohibited in all circumstances. No case-by-case assessment, no need to show the practice influenced a consumer’s decision | If your claim matches, it is unlawful. There is no argument about context |
| Articles 6 and 7 (misleading actions and omissions) | Case-by-case, subject to a “transactional decision test” — would the average consumer have decided differently? | Context and presentation matter; enforcement has to build a case |
Most of the pain for packaging sits in the first row.
The blacklist, in plain terms
| New Annex I point | What is banned | Canned-food example |
|---|---|---|
| 4a | A generic environmental claim where you cannot demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance | “Eco-friendly can”, “green packaging”, “climate-friendly packaging” |
| 4b | An environmental claim about the entire product, or the trader’s entire business, when it concerns only a certain aspect of the product or a specific activity of the business | “Made with recycled material” on the front of a can when only the outer carton is recycled; or a company-wide green claim resting on one plant |
| 4c | Claiming neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse-gas impact based on offsetting | “Carbon neutral” on a can where the neutrality comes from a reforestation project outside your value chain |
| 2a | Displaying a sustainability label not based on a certification scheme and not established by public authorities | A leaf-and-globe badge your design agency created for the range |
| 10a | Presenting legally required features as a distinctive feature of your offer | Marketing a compliance obligation that applies to every competing product on the EU market as though it were your advantage |
Recital 9 of the directive gives the working list of generic terms: environmentally friendly, eco-friendly, green, nature, ecological, environmentally correct, climate friendly, gentle on the environment, carbon friendly, energy efficient, biodegradable, biobased, climate-friendly packaging.
Note the last two. “Biodegradable” and “biobased” are on the generic list. Competing formats have leaned on both for years.
The three problems specific to a can
1. Your artwork may be making claims you never wrote
This is not an inference drawn by lawyers after the fact. Recital 9 of the directive closes with the line: “Furthermore, a claim made in written form or orally combined with implicit claims such as colours or images could constitute a generic environmental claim..”
The Commission was then asked directly whether decorative elements count. The answer, in Q5 of its FAQ, is that green leaves, water drops and similar nature icons “may be interpreted by consumers as implicit environmental claims” and, depending on context, may fall within the definition of a sustainability label — which the directive draws broadly enough to cover “voluntary trust mark, quality mark or equivalent, either public or private, that aims to set apart and promote a product, a process or a business by reference to its environmental or social characteristics, or both, and excludes any mandatory label required un”.
The existing UCPD guidance the Commission points back to goes further, and it names colour:
Accordingly, also the imagery and overall product presentation (i.e. layout, choice of colours, images, pictures, sounds, symbols or labels), should be a truthful and accurate representation of the scale of the environmental benefit, and should not overstate the benefit achieved. Implicit claims may, depending on the circumstances of the case, include the use of images (e.g.
A green background, a leaf beside the product name, a water droplet near a sustainability line — none of these are text, and all of them can be read as a claim.
One procedural point that matters more than it looks: the “average consumer” benchmark is not a statistical test. A national authority does not need a consumer survey or an expert report to decide that your leaf reads as an eco-badge. It can assess presumed consumer expectations directly.
2. A can has no room for the specification — and that is not an excuse
The whole generic-versus-specific distinction turns on whether the qualifying detail appears “in clear and prominent terms on the same medium”. A can label is a narrow band that already carries mandatory nutrition, ingredient and allergen information, net quantity, batch code, best-before date and the producer’s address under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. The space for a qualifying sentence next to a green claim is, in practice, not there.
The Commission’s guidance is explicit about what happens then:
If there is no space to specify the environmental claim, then the claim should generally not be made. By analogy, in the area of nutrition and health claims on foods, point 3 of the Annex to Commission Implementing Decision 2013/63/EU (310) provides that when referring to general, non-specific health benefits, it is required to accompany such references by a specific health claim from the lists of permitted health claims in the Union Register.
For canned food this is the single most consequential sentence in the whole file. It means the realistic options on-pack are: a claim short enough to carry its own specification, a claim backed by a recognised ecolabel, or no claim at all — with the fuller story moved to the website or a QR destination.
3. Old stock is in scope
There is no grandfathering. Q18 of the Commission FAQ states that from 27 September the rules apply “including for existing products or ‘old stock’ situations, i.e. products or packaging already manufactured, ordered, distributed or placed on retailers’ shelves before the application date.”
What the FAQ does offer is a practical route. Compliance for already-printed packaging “may include covering or correcting claims by stickers or adding supplementary information at the point of sale”. Enforcement sits with national authorities, who “may include in their assessment, for example, whether traders have made reasonable and proportionate efforts to comply, including for products already in the distribution chain”. The Consumer Protection Cooperation Network has developed a Common Understanding specifically on old-stock situations.
Translated into procurement terms: if you have a print run in the warehouse with a non-compliant claim, the answer is a documented remediation plan, not silence.
What you can still say
The directive does not ban environmental communication. It bans vague environmental communication. Four routes remain open.
Route 1 — make the claim specific, on the same medium. “100 % of energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources” is the Commission’s own example of a claim that is not caught by the generic prohibition. The specification must sit next to, or as part of, the claim.
Route 2 — earn a recognised ecolabel. A generic claim is lawful if you can demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance, and the FAQ narrows that to exactly three ways: the EU Ecolabel under Regulation (EC) No 66/2010; a national or regional EN ISO 14024 Type I scheme officially recognised in a member state — the FAQ names Nordic Swan, Blue Angel, the Austrian Ecolabel and Milieukeur; or top environmental performance under other applicable Union law. The performance must be relevant to the claim you are making: an ecolabel with no biodegradability criteria cannot support a “biodegradable” claim.
Route 3 — talk about real reductions, not offsets. Point 4c catches offsetting outside the value chain. It does not catch claims built on the product’s actual lifecycle. The FAQ is direct: it is allowed to state that a product has a “reduced CO2 impact” if this is specified in clear and prominent terms on the same medium and based on actual improvements in the production processes. Company-level offsetting claims fall outside 4c, though they remain exposed to the rest of the UCPD.
Route 4 — commit properly to the future. Claims about future environmental performance are not banned outright; under Article 6(2)(d) they need clear, objective, publicly available and verifiable commitments, set out in a detailed and realistic implementation plan, with independent third-party monitoring.
There is one more trap worth naming. Article 6(2)(e) makes it misleading to advertise benefits that are irrelevant and do not result from any feature of the product. The Commission’s illustrations are gluten-free bottled water and plastic-free paper. The test is cumulative — the benefit has to be both irrelevant and not a real feature — but the direction of travel is clear: do not advertise as an achievement something every can on the shelf already has.
Why this regulation is, on balance, good news for metal
Most packaging regulation of the last three years has been a cost for the canned-food category. This one is not, for a structural reason: it destroys vague claims and rewards documented ones, and metal’s environmental story is unusually documentable.
A steel or aluminium can has properties that can be stated numerically and evidenced from the supply chain: the recycled content of the substrate, named by mill and data year; the actual collection and recycling performance published by national schemes; the fact that the material is recycled through an existing, mature infrastructure rather than an aspirational one. None of that requires an adjective.
The claims that die on 27 September are disproportionately the ones that competing formats have relied on — “biodegradable”, “biobased”, “eco”, and offset-based neutrality. Those words are on the Recital 9 list or in point 4c.
But do not assume metal’s own favourite lines are safe. Two in particular need review:
- “100% recyclable” — a bare recyclability claim about a multi-component pack risks point 4b if it describes the whole product while only part qualifies, and risks 4a if it carries no specification. Say what is recyclable, in which stream, and where.
- “Infinitely recyclable” / “permanent material” — these are strong claims. They are defensible, but they are claims, and after 27 September a claim you cannot evidence in the form you printed it is a liability rather than a differentiator.
And one specific caution on point 10a: as PPWR obligations phase in, features that are mandatory for every can on the EU market cannot be marketed as your distinctive advantage. Recital 15 gives the test — the prohibition does not bite where the legal requirement applies only to some competing products in the category and not others, “such as products of non-Union origin”.
The recital’s own worked example happens to be a canned-food one. It states that “For example, as regards fish products produced sustainably in accordance with Union law, it would be allowed to promote the sustainability characteristics of those products that comply with Union legal requirements, if fish products of third country origin offered on the Union market are not required to comply with those Union legal requirements.” If your compliance genuinely exceeds what imported competitors must meet, saying so remains lawful. If it is a level playing field, it is not a selling point.
The part that concerns your can supplier
Here is the structural point most coverage of this directive misses: the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive is strictly business-to-consumer. The Commission’s FAQ is unambiguous — “The Directive is strictly limited to B2C practices. Business-to-business (B2B) commercial practices fall outside its scope.”
So your can maker is not directly liable under this directive for what it tells you. You are liable for what you print. B2B claims are governed elsewhere — the Misleading and Comparative Advertising Directive (2006/114/EC) and, for the agri-food supply chain, Directive (EU) 2019/633 on unfair trading practices.
That asymmetry has a practical consequence. Every environmental sentence on your label traces back to something a supplier told you, and from 27 September the regulatory risk of that sentence sits entirely on your side of the invoice. The mitigation is documentary, and it is the same discipline you already run for food-contact compliance.
Ask your can supplier, in writing:
- Recycled content of the substrate, as a percentage, by mill and by data year — not a range, not “up to”.
- The basis for any recyclability statement you intend to print: which stream, in which member states, and against which methodology.
- Whether any environmental figure they have given you is offset-based — because if it is, and you print it as a product-level neutrality claim, that is point 4c.
- Energy and process claims they have made about the plant, with the boundary stated: is “renewable electricity” site-level, company-level, or attributed to your order?
- Whether any figure comes from a certification scheme, and if so which — and whether that scheme is a certification scheme within the meaning of the directive or a private mark.
- Data year and refresh cadence for every number, so your artwork does not outlive its evidence.
Keep the answers with the artwork approval file. If an authority asks why you printed a number, the answer should be a document with a date on it.
What to do, in order
- Inventory every environmental claim across the range — text, badges and imagery, on every SKU and every language variant. Include the back-of-pack and the QR destination, not only the front.
- Sort each claim into three buckets: blacklisted (fix now), specific-and-evidenced (keep, file the evidence), and unevidenced-but-not-blacklisted (fix or drop).
- Flag the artwork elements nobody logged as claims — leaves, droplets, globes, green fields, self-made badges.
- Decide the on-pack versus off-pack split. If the specification does not fit, the claim does not go on the can. Move it to the website and, where you have one, the QR destination.
- Take a decision on printed stock, in writing, with dates: sticker, point-of-sale information, or sell-through with a documented plan. The FAQ tells you authorities may weigh reasonable and proportionate effort — that only helps if the effort is on paper.
- Send the six supplier questions above and file the answers against each SKU.
One thing you do not need to wait for: the separate Green Claims Directive, which would have set a harmonised methodology for substantiating claims, is not arriving on any usable timetable. The Commission announced its intention to withdraw the proposal on 20 June 2025, and the final trilogue scheduled for 23 June 2025 was cancelled by the Council. It has not been formally withdrawn — Parliament has signalled it would resume negotiations — but the file is dormant with no timetable, and it is not a plan you can build against. The regime that applies on 27 September is this one, and it applies without a harmonised substantiation methodology to lean on.
A related provision worth knowing if you publish comparisons: the directive adds a new paragraph 7 to Article 7 of the UCPD, making the method of comparison, the products compared, the suppliers and the measures keeping the information current all “material information” where a trader provides a service comparing products on environmental or circularity characteristics such as durability, reparability or recyclability.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Empowering Consumers Directive apply to business-to-business claims?
No. The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive it amends is strictly business-to-consumer, and the European Commission’s FAQ states this explicitly. B2B claims are covered instead by the Misleading and Comparative Advertising Directive (2006/114/EC) and, in the agri-food supply chain, by Directive (EU) 2019/633. In practice this means the brand that prints the claim carries the risk, not the packaging supplier that supplied the underlying figure.
Can I still print “recyclable” on a can after 27 September 2026?
Yes, if the claim is specific and accurate. The prohibitions catch claims that are generic (no specification on the same medium) or that describe the whole product when only part qualifies. State what is recyclable, in which stream and where, and hold evidence for it. A bare “100% recyclable” across a multi-component pack is the risky formulation.
What happens to cans already printed and in the warehouse?
They are in scope from 27 September 2026 — the rules cover packaging already manufactured, ordered, distributed or on retailers’ shelves. The Commission’s FAQ points to practical remedies including stickers and supplementary information at the point of sale, and notes that enforcement authorities may take account of whether a trader made reasonable and proportionate efforts. Document the decision.
Are green leaves and nature imagery on packaging now prohibited?
Not prohibited as such, but they can be read as implicit environmental claims or as a sustainability label, particularly when placed next to a written claim or a logo. The assessment uses the “average consumer” benchmark, which is not a statistical test — an authority can reach that conclusion without a consumer survey.
Is “carbon neutral” banned on packaging?
It is banned where the neutrality rests on offsetting greenhouse gas emissions outside the product’s value chain — that is Annex I point 4c, and Recital 12 lists climate neutral, CO2 neutral certified, carbon positive, climate net zero, climate compensated, reduced climate impact, limited CO2 footprint as examples. A claim built on the product’s actual lifecycle impact is not caught, and “reduced CO2 impact” remains available if it is specified on the same medium and based on real improvements in production.
How do I make a generic claim like “eco-friendly” lawfully?
Only by demonstrating recognised excellent environmental performance, which the FAQ limits to three routes: the EU Ecolabel under Regulation (EC) No 66/2010; a national or regional EN ISO 14024 Type I ecolabelling scheme officially recognised in a member state, such as Nordic Swan, Blue Angel, the Austrian Ecolabel or Milieukeur; or top environmental performance under other applicable Union law. The performance must be relevant to the specific claim.
Sources and primary references
- Directive (EU) 2024/825 — Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition; transposition 27 March 2026, application 27 September 2026
- European Commission — Questions & Answers on the ECGT Directive — scope, generic claims, packaging artwork, recognised excellent environmental performance, offsetting, old stock
- Directive 2005/29/EC — Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, as amended
- Directive 2011/83/EU — Consumer Rights Directive, as amended
- Commission Notice 2021/C 526/01 — UCPD Guidance, sections 4.1.1.3–4.1.1.4 on imagery and on claims where space is limited
- Regulation (EC) No 66/2010 — EU Ecolabel
- Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 — food information to consumers, the mandatory content competing for label space
- Directive 2006/114/EC — Misleading and Comparative Advertising (B2B)
- Directive (EU) 2019/633 — unfair trading practices in the agricultural and food supply chain
- Regulation (EU) 2025/40 — PPWR, relevant to point 10a as obligations phase in
A note on the quotations. Passages from Directive (EU) 2024/825 and from Commission Notice 2021/C 526/01 are reproduced from the official EU-language version of those texts, so the wording in each language edition of this article is the wording the legislator published. The exception is the Russian edition: the European Union does not issue Russian-language versions of its legal acts, so there the quotations are an unofficial translation and the English original governs. Passages from the Commission’s Questions & Answers document, which is published in English only, are rendered from that English original in every edition.
This article is general commercial guidance, not legal advice. Enforcement of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive sits with national authorities and national transposition differs in detail; specific label copy, artwork and old-stock decisions should be reviewed with counsel qualified in the member states where you place product.
