Inconsistent Definitions of Compostable Packaging Hinder Market Growth, New Report Reveals

News, Sustainability | By: AkvaProfit Team
Date of publication: May 22, 2026

A recent report by a multi-stakeholder coalition has highlighted the fragmented definitions of compostable packaging as a significant obstacle to the advancement of compostable packaging systems. The report, titled ‘Breaking Solos, Building Bridges: A Collaborative Scan of Definitions for Compost and Compostable Packaging,’ indicates that varying definitions from organizations such as ASTM International, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and the Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment (CCME) contribute to confusion in the marketplace.

The inconsistency in definitions not only creates gaps between laboratory testing and actual composting performance but also leads to misalignment in product acceptance policies and regulatory fragmentation. This situation undermines confidence among brands, packaging designers, compost manufacturers, and consumers regarding the true compostability of products.

While definitions for ‘compost’ and ‘composting’ are largely consistent across authoritative sources, the report warns that the lack of a unified definition for compostability poses barriers to national consistency and market scalability. Furthermore, laboratory standards often do not reflect real-world disintegration outcomes in commercial composting systems, resulting in significant discrepancies based on composting technologies and facilities.

The coalition, formed during the 2024 Improving the Circularity of Compostables and Composting (IC3) Strategic Planning Event in Denver, aims to create a transparent, science-based, consensus-driven framework for compostability definitions and performance criteria that align with real-world conditions while remaining adaptable to future innovations.

Looking ahead, the coalition plans to release a follow-up report examining how existing standards and certifications translate into practical outcomes at compost manufacturing facilities. These efforts are intended to foster better policies, align certification with operational performance, and enhance confidence across the composting ecosystem.

In related developments, the U.S. Plastics Pact has issued a report suggesting ways for policymakers to enhance composting infrastructure and support compostable packaging systems, thereby diverting food waste and contaminated materials from landfills. Additionally, the Italian Ministry of Environment and Energy Security (MASE) has proposed a draft legislative measure to exempt biodegradable and compostable formats from the bans on single-use plastic packaging outlined in the Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation, a move that European Bioplastics has described as “positive and pragmatic.”

Request Basket